Born in Alpena, Michigan, Norman graduated from Evangelical Lutheran Seminary located in Columbus, Ohio in 1948. Rev. Wegmeyer served as the first pastor of Good Shepherd from 1952 until 1955.

Rev. Wegmeyer started the Church in the Maryland Avenue School and saw the completion of the mission package church building and the parsonage.  He also served as Director of Parish Education from 1959-1963. Other churches he served were in Farmersville, Ohio; Toledo, Ohio; and Butler, Pennsylvania.   Rev. Wegmeyer currently lives in Columbus.

 Rev. Robert T. Reiss

Born in New Philadelphia, Ohio, Robert graduated from Evangelical Lutheran Theological Seminary in 1954. He was chaplain in the US Navy 1954-56.

He was installed August 1956 and served until 1960. During his tenure confirmed membership grew to 270 members. Rev. Reiss also served as pastor in Mt Vernon, Ohio and Springfield, Ohio.  His twin brother Richard Reiss was also a pastor in Upper Arlington.

Born in Janera, Ohio, Richard completed programs at Evangelical Lutheran Theological Seminary in 1956, Capital University, State University of Iowa, and The Ohio State University for his doctorate.

Rev. Bosse served from 1960 until 1967 as the third pastor of Good Shepherd. He came to Good Shepherd Lutheran from New Lebanon Evangelical Lutheran in Junction City, Ohio. Rev. Bosse oversaw the completion of the education unit, installation of the stained glass windows and pews.

Born in Columbus Ohio, John was installed as Pastor at Good Shepherd in August 1967 and served until 1974. Prior to the seminary he attended Case University of Pennsylvania, and Western Reserve. Rev Kromer completed Seminary training at Evangelical Lutheran Theological Seminary. In 1963. Prior to Good Shepherd he served as pastor in Sandusky, Ohio. The Kromers have six children.

During his tenure the Alpha Omega scripting behind the altar was added to the sanctuary. Church improvements included purchase of an organ, carpeting, improved nave lighting and balcony remodeling. Church programs expanded to weekday preschool and sponsorship of boy scout troops.

Born in Columbus, Ohio, Bill graduated from Capital University and then completed his theological training at Trinity Lutheran Seminary. Serving Good Shepherd from 1975 until 1983, his ministry included services at the airport Drive In theater and puppets. He also installed a speaker system to communicate services to homebound members by telephone.

Prior to Good Shepherd he served as pastor in Derwood, Maryland; Huron, Ohio; and Poland, Ohio. The Mercers have three children: Peter, Joy and Paul. 

David was born in 1954 at Cherrypoint, N.C. and attended Texas Lutheran College, Sequin, Texas, from which he graduated with a B.A. in 1976. He then attended Trinity Lutheran Seminary, Columbus, graduating in June 1980. Ordained August 24, 1980, he began his ministry as pastor of St. John Lutheran Church, Logan, Ohio where he was serving in 1983 when Good Shepherd called him.  Pastor Connor was installed 1983 and served until 1988. He developed the symbol of the Good Shepherd still used on the stationary today.

Pastor Connor is married to Pastor Paula Maeder Connor. They have two daughters: Brenna and Greer.

Born 1956 in Alliance, Ohio, Connie graduated in 1980 from Bowling Green State University and was a Parish Worker at Bethany English Lutheran Church, Cleveland Ohio from 1981 to 1982. In 1986 she graduated from Trinity Lutheran Seminary and accepted her first call at Faith Lutheran Church in Jackson, OH.

Serving at Good Shepherd from 1989 until 1995, financial concerns and decreasing membership were major challenges in her ministry.  Community involvement included entrance of floats in the Bexley parade and Headstart programs. She married Timothy Mentzer September 17 1994.

Having graduated from Hiram College with a degree in Elementary Education in 1971, Louise worked as an elementary school librarian, reading specialist and classroom teacher. She received a Master of Divinity degree from Trinity Lutheran Seminary May 1992 and was ordained July 19, 1992. Rev. Mollick served Zion Lutheran Church in North Canton, Ohio from 1992 until 1996. She was installed at Good Shepherd in 1996 and served until 1998.

Rev. Mollick instituted the use of the chant Holy Spirit Come To Us used after the petitions in the prayers. She is married to Carl Mollick and has three children: Daniel, Jessica and Stephen.

Called to serve May 2001 supporting a two point parish in conjunction with Reformation Lutheran church.

Pastor Kathy was born in Ironton, Ohio. She graduated from Franklin University and later completed her Master of Divinity From Trinity Lutheran seminary in 1987. Her first call was to Faith Lutheran in Jackson Ohio. She brings a background from the business world of sales. Kathy and Sam have a daughter, Stephanie.